• Question: how far is nature more important that nurture in the early development of children and how may this affect them in later life if handled ineffectively?

    Asked by anon-181677 on 20 Jun 2018.
    • Photo: Liza Selley

      Liza Selley answered on 20 Jun 2018:


      I think nature and nurture are both very important if you include physical and behavioural traits in ‘development’.

      For the nature argument….As a toxicologist I study a concept called the ‘exposome’ which is basically a collection of all the things we have been exposed to throughout our lives – chemicals, medicines, foods, stress, pollution, disease etc. These exposures can greatly impact on our health but also on the health of any children we may have in the future as many chemicals and stresses can affect their physical development in the womb and in later life. Similarly, if someone has a genetic defect they can pass this on to their children.

      For the nurture argument… the way that we bond with our parents can have an enormous impact on the relationships that we develop with friends, partners and colleagues later in life. Similarly, the rules, ideas and ways of the world that our parents teach us help to shape our behaviour and personality. Documentaries about serial killers provide an excellent example of when this goes wrong!

    • Photo: Laura Hemming

      Laura Hemming answered on 24 Jun 2018:


      Coming from a Psychological perspective, I think that I would tend to argue that there’s slightly more of an influence from the ‘nurture’ side of things than there is for the ‘nature’ side. But this is probably specific to mental health as opposed to health more generally. There is lots of research currently which shows that experiencing a stressful or traumatic event in childhood can lead to lots of adverse mental health outcomes later on in life. These can include things like schizophrenia and depression. This isn’t to say, however, that these people can’t be helped. In fact there are lots of therapies which are focussed on reappraising traumatic events to make sure that they don’t have an undue influence on a person’s mental health.

Comments